One of the most common questions we hear from people charged with assault family violence in Travis County is whether the alleged victim can simply ask for the charges to be dropped.
In many family violence cases, the alleged victim does not want the criminal prosecution to move forward. Sometimes they never wanted the defendant arrested in the first place. Other times, they initially supported the prosecution but later changed their mind.
So, can the alleged victim drop family violence charges? The short answer is no. But their wishes can still have a significant impact on how the case is resolved.
Why Would an Alleged Victim Want Charges Dropped?
There are many reasons why someone might not want to proceed with a family violence prosecution.
For example:
The parties want to reconcile. The alleged victim may want to continue the relationship and move past the incident.
They believe the incident was exaggerated or misunderstood. Sometimes the complaining witness believes the police misunderstood what happened or that the original allegations do not accurately reflect the incident.
They are concerned about the consequences for their family. A criminal conviction can affect employment, finances, housing, and the ability of the parties to continue living together.
They do not believe the defendant deserves criminal punishment. Even when the alleged victim acknowledges that an argument became physical, they may believe counseling or other intervention would be more appropriate than a criminal conviction.
They do not want to participate in court proceedings. Testifying against a spouse, partner, or family member can be emotionally difficult.
They believe the allegations are false. In some cases, the complaining witness maintains that no assault occurred and wants to correct the information provided to law enforcement.
Of course, there are also situations in which a complaining witness may feel pressured, intimidated, or financially dependent on the defendant. Prosecutors are aware of these possibilities and may be reluctant to dismiss a case simply because the alleged victim requests it.
Whatever the reason, it is not unusual for the complaining witness to oppose prosecution.
CONTACT ATX LEGAL
Criminal Defense
Who Decides Whether Family Violence Charges Are Dropped?
In Texas, the decision to pursue or dismiss criminal charges ultimately belongs to the prosecutor, not the alleged victim.
Once someone is arrested for assault family violence, the case is prosecuted by the State of Texas. The complaining witness does not become a party to the criminal case and cannot independently dismiss the charges.
In Travis County, misdemeanor assault family violence cases are generally handled by the Travis County Attorney’s Office, while felony cases are prosecuted by the Travis County District Attorney’s Office.
This means that even if the complaining witness tells the prosecutor that they want the charges dropped, the prosecutor can continue with the case.
However, the fact that the complaining witness cannot dismiss the charges does not mean their opinion is irrelevant.
Quite the opposite. Their position can be one of the most important considerations in how a family violence case is handled.
How Important Is the Complaining Witness’s Opinion?
In many assault family violence cases, the complaining witness is the State’s most important witness.
Often, the alleged incident occurred in a private residence without any independent witnesses. The prosecution may rely heavily on the complaining witness’s account to establish what happened.
If that person does not want to participate in the prosecution, it can create significant challenges for the State.
For example, the prosecutor may have difficulty establishing the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt without the complaining witness’s testimony.
However, the State may have other evidence, including:
911 recordings.
Police body camera footage.
Photographs of alleged injuries.
Medical records.
Statements made to responding officers.
Testimony from other witnesses.
Text messages or other electronic communications.
Depending on the circumstances and the rules of evidence, some of this information may be admissible even without the complaining witness’s cooperation.
Consequently, an uncooperative complaining witness does not automatically mean that the prosecution cannot prove its case.
Nevertheless, their position can substantially affect the prosecutor’s assessment of the evidence and the likelihood of obtaining a conviction.
What Is an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution?
One way a complaining witness can communicate their wishes is through an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution, sometimes called an ANP.
An affidavit of non-prosecution is a written statement in which the complaining witness explains that they do not want the criminal prosecution to proceed.
Depending on the circumstances, the affidavit might explain that the complaining witness does not fear the defendant, does not believe prosecution is necessary, or would prefer that the case be resolved without a criminal conviction.
It may also provide additional information about the incident or correct inaccuracies in an earlier statement.
Importantly, an affidavit of non-prosecution is not a legal mechanism that automatically dismisses a criminal case.
The prosecutor can consider the affidavit and still decide to proceed.
However, a properly prepared affidavit can be useful in plea negotiations and may contribute to a decision to dismiss the charges.
Any statement should be truthful and voluntary. A complaining witness should never be pressured to sign an affidavit or encouraged to change an accurate account of what occurred.
Contacting Travis County Victim Services
Another way for the complaining witness to express their wishes is by communicating directly with the prosecuting attorney’s office.
In misdemeanor assault family violence cases, the complaining witness may communicate with the Travis County Attorney’s Office, including its victim services personnel. For felony cases, the appropriate contact is generally the Travis County District Attorney’s Office.
Victim services personnel can help communicate the complaining witness’s concerns and preferences to the prosecutor handling the case.
For example, the complaining witness may explain that they do not want the defendant prosecuted, that they do not fear further violence, or that the existing no-contact restrictions are creating difficulties for the family.
The prosecutor is not required to follow these wishes. Nevertheless, this information may influence how the State evaluates the case and whether a particular resolution is appropriate.
Texas law also recognizes certain rights of family violence victims to communicate their views regarding dismissal, plea agreements, and other case dispositions.
Can an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution Lead to Dismissal?
Yes. In some cases, the complaining witness’s position can contribute to a dismissal.
There are two principal reasons.
1. The Prosecutor May Have Difficulty Proving the Case
As discussed above, the complaining witness is frequently the State’s central witness.
If the complaining witness does not support the prosecution, the prosecutor must consider whether the remaining admissible evidence is sufficient to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.
For example, suppose the only witnesses to an alleged assault were the defendant and the complaining witness. There are no photographs of injuries, no independent witnesses, and no other substantial evidence.
If the complaining witness does not support the allegations, the prosecutor may determine that obtaining a conviction would be difficult.
In those circumstances, dismissal may become a realistic possibility.
On the other hand, if the State has substantial independent evidence, the case may proceed even without the complaining witness’s support.
2. The Complaining Witness’s Wishes May Affect Plea Negotiations
The complaining witness’s position can also influence the prosecutor’s assessment of the seriousness of the case and the appropriate resolution.
For example, if the complaining witness explains that the incident was isolated, that they do not fear the defendant, and that they would prefer a resolution involving counseling rather than punishment, the prosecutor may consider that information during plea negotiations.
Depending on the circumstances, this could contribute to a more favorable plea offer, consideration of a diversion program, or dismissal.
Of course, the prosecutor will also consider other factors, including the severity of the allegations, the defendant’s criminal history, evidence of prior family violence, and any ongoing safety concerns.
The complaining witness’s wishes are important, but they are only one part of the prosecutor’s decision.
How Does the Complaining Witness Make a Statement?
If the complaining witness does not want the prosecution to proceed, one option is to speak with the defendant’s criminal defense attorney about the available procedures.
The attorney can explain how an affidavit of non-prosecution works, how the complaining witness’s position may affect the case, and how that information can be communicated to the prosecutor.
However, the defendant’s attorney represents the defendant, not the complaining witness. The complaining witness is free to seek independent legal advice and can communicate directly with the prosecutor or victim services without going through the defense attorney.
It is also important to understand that any existing no-contact bond condition or protective order must be respected. The defendant should not contact the complaining witness in violation of a court order, even for the purpose of discussing the criminal case.
The decision to provide a statement must belong to the complaining witness and must be made voluntarily.
What If the Alleged Victim Wants the Charges Dropped?
If you have been charged with assault family violence in Travis County and the complaining witness does not want to proceed, that information may be very important to your defense.
However, it does not mean the case will automatically be dismissed.
An experienced criminal defense attorney can evaluate the evidence, communicate with the prosecutor, and determine how the complaining witness’s position may affect the available options.
At ATX Legal, we represent individuals charged with assault family violence in Travis County, including cases in which the complaining witness does not want the prosecution to continue.
We can help evaluate the evidence, address bond conditions and protective orders, and pursue an appropriate resolution based on the circumstances of the case.
Contact ATX Legal to discuss your assault family violence case and your available defense options.